The Pakistan Experience
The Pakistan Experience
  • 637
  • 34 368 405
Is Pakistan's Master Narrative Anti-India and Anti-Hindu? - Two Pakistans - Shehzad Ghias #TPE
Is Pakistan's Master Narrative Anti-India and Anti-Hindu?
Episode 2 of Two Pakistans looks at Pakistan's Master Narrative, the Secular Liberal vs Islamist Debate in Pakistan, What Pakistan Quaid-e-Azam wanted, the treatment of religious minorities in Pakistan, the conflict between traditionalists and modernists in the Muslim League and how Pakistan has created a nation without history.
Our new series, Two Pakistans, looks at the conflicts in Pakistan and uses Dr. Mohammad Waseem's book, "Political Conflict in Pakistan" to explain the fault lines in Pakistan.
The Pakistan Experience is an independently produced podcast looking to tell stories about Pakistan through conversations.
Please consider supporting us on Patreon:
www.patreon.com/thepakistanexperience
To support the channel:
Jazzcash/Easypaisa - 0325 -2982912
Patreon.com/thepakistanexperience
And Please stay in touch:
ThePakistanExp1
thepakistanexperience
thepakistanexpeperience
The podcast is hosted by comedian and writer, Shehzad Ghias Shaikh. Shehzad is a Fulbright scholar with a Masters in Theatre from Brooklyn College. He is also one of the foremost Stand-up comedians in Pakistan and frequently writes for numerous publications.
shehzadghiasshaikh
Facebook.com/Shehzadghias/
shehzad89
Chapters:
0:00 Introduction
1:20 Does Pakistan Studies teach Hindu Hate?
7:00 Creating a Nation without History and Pakistan's Master Narrative
9:00 How America pushed Pakistan into Jehadism
13:00 Creating a Hindu Demon for Pakistan's Master Narrative
21:00 Enforcement of Identities and the Language Issue
24:00 Why don't we tell Pakistan's History?
28:00 Three Categories of Pakistan's Master Narrative
35:00 Islamists vs Modernists
Переглядів: 20 064

Відео

Was PTI the political wing of the Military Establishment? - From 2011 Jalsa to 9th May - #TPE
Переглядів 27 тис.7 годин тому
A year on from 9th May 2023, we look back at the past year, from PTI being relaunched in 2011 to the 2014 Dharna, the 2017 movement against democracy, the 2018 Elections, the Hybrid Regime and the ouster of Imran Khan, we look at how the Military Establishment made in roads in Pakistan and the space for free media, democracy and civilian supremacy shrunk in Pakistan. Was Imran Khan the spokespe...
Freedom to Preach, Elite Hypocrisy and Johar Boys - Live Fraudcast - Audience Q/A - #TPE 360
Переглядів 21 тис.9 годин тому
The second ever live podcast of The Pakistan Experience with an audience with the legendary Chaudhry Brothers - Murtaza and Mustafa! Mustafa Chaudhry and Murtaza Chaudhry join Shehzad Ghias Shaikh for a Live Fraudcast with the crowd where we discuss Criticism, Freedom of Speech, Maryam Nawaz wearing a Police Uniform, Being Critical of the Elite, Johar Boys, Freedom to Preach and how to find hop...
How Ayub Khan destroyed the Political Class in Pakistan - Pakistan Lost - #TPE
Переглядів 18 тис.12 годин тому
Pakistan Lost is a series of audio essays on history exploring the choices that were made that impacted millions of people for decades to come. The Sixth episode looks at the Creation of Bangladesh. Watch all the episodes of Pakistan Lost in Urdu: ua-cam.com/video/cEh4HSt8V-E/v-deo.html The Pakistan Experience is an independently produced podcast looking to tell stories about Pakistan through c...
PTI Bias, Zaid Hamid and Audience Q/A with Tamkenat Mansoor, Mustafa Chaudhry and Aamir Mughal #TPE
Переглядів 47 тис.День тому
The first ever live podcast of The Pakistan Experience where the audience got to ask questions from us! Tamkenat Mansoor, Mustafa Chaudhry and Aamir Mughal join Shehzad Ghias Shaikh for a hilarious and thought provoking interaction with the crowd where we discuss Content Creation, Censorship, Stand-up Girl, Comedy, Satire, Zaid Hamid, Zakir Naik, Counter Culture, PTI Bias, Mental Health and mor...
Bhutto, Mujib and Yahya Khan - 1971 Bangladesh kee Sachayee kya hay? - Pakistan Lost - #TPE
Переглядів 127 тис.День тому
Pakistan Lost is a series of audio essays on history exploring the choices that were made that impacted millions of people for decades to come. The Fifth episode looks at the Creation of Bangladesh. Watch all the episodes of Pakistan Lost in Urdu: ua-cam.com/video/cEh4HSt8V-E/v-deo.html The Pakistan Experience is an independently produced podcast looking to tell stories about Pakistan through c...
Birth of Islamic Pakistan and Political Conflict in Karachi - Two Pakistans - Shehzad Ghias #TPE
Переглядів 46 тис.14 днів тому
Our new series, Two Pakistans, looks at the conflicts in Pakistan and uses Dr. Mohammad Waseem's book, "Political Conflict in Pakistan" to explain the fault lines in Pakistan. Episode 1 looks at the use of the Islamic Identity as the identity of Pakistan at the birth of the nation, partition, colonialism and Political Conflict in Karachi. The Pakistan Experience is an independently produced pod...
Kya Urdu ko as a National Language Pakistan kay oopar impose kiya gaya - Pakistan Lost - #TPE
Переглядів 42 тис.14 днів тому
Pakistan Lost is a series of audio essays on history exploring the choices that were made that impacted millions of people for decades to come. The Fourth episode looks at the Imposition of Urdu as a National Language on Pakistan: Watch all the episodes of Pakistan Lost in Urdu: ua-cam.com/video/cEh4HSt8V-E/v-deo.html The Pakistan Experience is an independently produced podcast looking to tell ...
Art, Aftab Iqbal's Mentality and Religious Hypocrisy in Pakistan - Adeel Afzal - #TPE 358
Переглядів 92 тис.21 день тому
Writer, Actor and Content Creator Adeel Afzal is comes back on the podcast for a pure fire episode of The Pakistan Experience where we discuss the controversy between Sohail Ahmed and Aftab Iqbal, lay bare the religious hypocrisy present in Pakistan and break down the idea of Art and Culture in our country. On this week's episode, we discuss Aftab Iqbal's Mentality, Industry kay Babay, Amanulla...
Which Election was the worst? - Election Analysis 2008 to 2024 - Shehzad Ghias #TPE
Переглядів 24 тис.Місяць тому
Which Election was the worst? - Election Analysis 2008 to 2024 - Shehzad Ghias #TPE
The Journey of TPE, Euro Trip and Using Children for Content - Sajeer Shaikh - Shehzad Ghias - #TPE
Переглядів 27 тис.Місяць тому
The Journey of TPE, Euro Trip and Using Children for Content - Sajeer Shaikh - Shehzad Ghias - #TPE
Was Pakistan created for Minority Rights? Pakistan Lost ft Dr Ishtiaq Ahmad - #TPE
Переглядів 24 тис.Місяць тому
Was Pakistan created for Minority Rights? Pakistan Lost ft Dr Ishtiaq Ahmad - #TPE
Democracy vs Dictatorship - - Stolen Elections 1977 to 2008 Shehzad Ghias - #TPE
Переглядів 25 тис.Місяць тому
Democracy vs Dictatorship - - Stolen Elections 1977 to 2008 Shehzad Ghias - #TPE
Why is Balochistan ignored by the Mainstream Media? - Waqas Alam on Gwadar Flooding - #TPE 356
Переглядів 64 тис.Місяць тому
Why is Balochistan ignored by the Mainstream Media? - Waqas Alam on Gwadar Flooding - #TPE 356
Counter Culture, Alternative Discourse and the journey of The Pakistan Experience
Переглядів 31 тис.Місяць тому
Counter Culture, Alternative Discourse and the journey of The Pakistan Experience
A history of Islamic touch politics in Pakistan - Separate Electorates - Pakistan Lost - #TPE
Переглядів 30 тис.Місяць тому
A history of Islamic touch politics in Pakistan - Separate Electorates - Pakistan Lost - #TPE
History of Stolen Elections in Pakistan 1947-1970 - Shehzad Ghias - #TPE
Переглядів 32 тис.Місяць тому
History of Stolen Elections in Pakistan 1947-1970 - Shehzad Ghias - #TPE
Colonialism, Religion and the Tablighi Jamaat - Arsalan Khan - #TPE 355
Переглядів 40 тис.Місяць тому
Colonialism, Religion and the Tablighi Jamaat - Arsalan Khan - #TPE 355
Resistance, Revolution, PTM and Mahrang Baloch - Ismat Raza Shahjehan - #TPE 354
Переглядів 47 тис.Місяць тому
Resistance, Revolution, PTM and Mahrang Baloch - Ismat Raza Shahjehan - #TPE 354
Pakistan ka matlab kya? - Lahore Resolution vs Pakistan Resolution - Urdu - Pakistan Lost - #TPE
Переглядів 29 тис.Місяць тому
Pakistan ka matlab kya? - Lahore Resolution vs Pakistan Resolution - Urdu - Pakistan Lost - #TPE
Understanding Islam, Javed Ghamidi, Shariah and the Establishment - Muhammad Hassan Ilyas - #TPE 353
Переглядів 90 тис.Місяць тому
Understanding Islam, Javed Ghamidi, Shariah and the Establishment - Muhammad Hassan Ilyas - #TPE 353
IMF, Military Governments, Bureaucracy and the Economy - Ishrat Husain - #TPE 352
Переглядів 202 тис.Місяць тому
IMF, Military Governments, Bureaucracy and the Economy - Ishrat Husain - #TPE 352
Cultural Connections, Kartarpur and SouthAsia Peace - Beena Sarwar - Aman ki Asha - #TPE 352
Переглядів 98 тис.Місяць тому
Cultural Connections, Kartarpur and SouthAsia Peace - Beena Sarwar - Aman ki Asha - #TPE 352
22 of my Family members were killed in Gaza but I Shall Not Hate - Dr. Izzeldin Abuelaish - #TPE 350
Переглядів 9 тис.Місяць тому
22 of my Family members were killed in Gaza but I Shall Not Hate - Dr. Izzeldin Abuelaish - #TPE 350
The Mother's Mental Health, Depression and Pregnancy - Amn Karim Ahmad - #TPE 349
Переглядів 6 тис.Місяць тому
The Mother's Mental Health, Depression and Pregnancy - Amn Karim Ahmad - #TPE 349
Citizenship, State and Pakistan's use of Religion - Ali Usman Qasmi - #TPE 348
Переглядів 103 тис.2 місяці тому
Citizenship, State and Pakistan's use of Religion - Ali Usman Qasmi - #TPE 348
PTI vs PDM vs The Establishment - Who won the Election? - Shehzad Ghias - Elections Analysis - #TPE
Переглядів 44 тис.2 місяці тому
PTI vs PDM vs The Establishment - Who won the Election? - Shehzad Ghias - Elections Analysis - #TPE
Funding, Western Agenda and Elitist; Myths and Misconceptions - Aurat March Organizers - #TPE 347
Переглядів 19 тис.2 місяці тому
Funding, Western Agenda and Elitist; Myths and Misconceptions - Aurat March Organizers - #TPE 347
ISI, Taliban and Kashmir: A History of Militancy in Pakistan - Zahid Hussain - TPE 346
Переглядів 190 тис.2 місяці тому
ISI, Taliban and Kashmir: A History of Militancy in Pakistan - Zahid Hussain - TPE 346
Ali Amin Gandapur and the Future of Pakistan - Shehzad Ghias - #TPE Daily
Переглядів 44 тис.2 місяці тому
Ali Amin Gandapur and the Future of Pakistan - Shehzad Ghias - #TPE Daily

КОМЕНТАРІ

  • @CrezyBoy-tp9hk
    @CrezyBoy-tp9hk 8 хвилин тому

    Bhai I am indian but this video is nolejfull

  • @WHISPERER007
    @WHISPERER007 30 хвилин тому

    I support Shias,Ahmedia because Sunnism or Sunnitva is oppressive 😡😡

  • @TruthPrevailz
    @TruthPrevailz 32 хвилини тому

    Congress is not secular. Its a minority appeasing party. Muslims in india love congress for taking their votes and not doing anything for them in 70 years. Waqf act, not touching muslim laws, places of worship act are all examples.

  • @muhammadmohsin557
    @muhammadmohsin557 41 хвилина тому

    پاکستان کی سرکاری زبان اگر اردو ہو جاتی تو آپ تو آسمان سر پر اٹھا لیتے 😂😂😂

  • @TruthPrevailz
    @TruthPrevailz 41 хвилина тому

    This guys goes on about what pakistan reaches it's kids and then says pak and muslim are not the same !!!! Itna practical torture karke minorities ko fir bolo it's not the same. Senseless

  • @waqarhasan8922
    @waqarhasan8922 59 хвилин тому

    Well said sur

  • @suvendu8967
    @suvendu8967 Годину тому

    32:29 Ajj mar dete hey, kal bol denge oh hum log samjh nahi paye , sorry abb kar v keya sakte hey. Purane glati ka saja thori milega. Then repeat this again n again. Typical pakstani😑

  • @71espn
    @71espn Годину тому

    Hey shehzad talk to Ali Usman qasmi about his book muslims against the Muslim league. You didn't really discuss it last time.

  • @jigardhuvavia
    @jigardhuvavia 2 години тому

    A hindu temple cannot be made in Islamabad and land has been given in ayodhya to construct a mosque. But still muslims are in danger in India and Hindus are safe in Pakistan

  • @Malik-gv4pj
    @Malik-gv4pj 2 години тому

    Shame on you

  • @jitendrasinghsodha7292
    @jitendrasinghsodha7292 2 години тому

    😅🤣

  • @hasnynhashmi4636
    @hasnynhashmi4636 2 години тому

    very disappointed, sad to see how you mixed facts & lies to further your narrative, in the start you claimed that it will be an unbiased analysis but sadly the tilt is very clearly visible and the whole analysis is hypocritical

  • @zohaibhassan5291
    @zohaibhassan5291 2 години тому

    What has happened is gone now he khan is only one opposing establishment

  • @user-dh9gd1bl6i
    @user-dh9gd1bl6i 2 години тому

    THANKYOU SO MUCH SIR. Your Videos have become a regular medicine for me. I was suffering from insomnia and then I started watching your videos. I fell asleep while watching your videos and no more feel insomnic. Thankyou once again.

  • @akhilkumarchoudhury6363
    @akhilkumarchoudhury6363 2 години тому

    You can’t defy hate & support Jinnah. Don’t do that , that’s why left secularism failed in Pakistan. Jinnah created Pakistan out of hate , accept it warmly.

  • @indian9428
    @indian9428 3 години тому

    14:34 congress was created by Allan Octavian Hume and William Wedderburn they took some Indians with them like Womesh Chandra Bonnerjee , Pherozeshah Mehta , Badruddin Tyabji and Mahadev Govind Ranade who were ready to dance on British tunes , congress was created to see no armed revolution takes place in Bharat 16:04 if muhammad ali jinnah was not anti hindu then who gave the call of direct action day ?? 16:49 i don't no exact name but one Britisher actually said these ' we never did divide and rule their was always a divide we just exploited it ' 18:18 unfortunate with those Hindus who stayed their because what is happening with them and what are pakistani so called activist or liberals are doing to people like Miya Mithu is their any action taken on them ... and when i see all wox pox interviews or public reactions of lahore liberty chawk i see just radicalized people and its not just a aam radei walla or auto walla i have seen that comment from lawyers and so called educated peoples , and if this hindu muslim thing happens only in Bharat i would have thought that we might have some problem , this issue is happening in Europe and western countries , and if some one intrested in Datta then they should just cheack that how many percentage of Muslims are in western countries and what are the percentage of crime in which muslims are involved , Muslims gose in other countries for better life and then they demand for sharia some one should discuss on this

  • @Asim-ut5mg
    @Asim-ut5mg 3 години тому

    Yeh background ka music Nahin hona chahiye. Jo zrori cheez hai woh sunaae nahi deta. Shukria

  • @kanchavsoman7113
    @kanchavsoman7113 3 години тому

    I don't understand what is Pakistan identity, they are just converted people

  • @tanu4647
    @tanu4647 4 години тому

    But... You can't bring Dinosaurs back to earth then Pakistan will never bring back stability secularism democracy peace and Wtever 😢

  • @KingSolomon563
    @KingSolomon563 5 годин тому

    I'm from Dhaka, Bangladesh. I've heard 1971 incident from my grandparents. From 1947, we were being treated in an unwanted manner by west Pakistan. Bengalis were 56% by overall population of Pakistan then. But Pakistani leaders never recognised Bengali language. They never accepted our culture. 70% of the export products were from Bengal, but 75% of the budget was used to build west Pakistan. A lot of incidents had happened. Then came 1970 election. Sheikh Mujib won the election but west Pakistan didn’t handover the power. Rather started genocide on 25th march, 1971. Over 3 millions of Bengalis died in that 9 months of war. More than 2 lacs of women had been raped. My grandfather always cried whenever he talked about 1971. Pakistan owe a national apology to my beloved Bangladesh. We know what a nightmare it was for us.

  • @wasilkhan2514
    @wasilkhan2514 5 годин тому

    One of the most disgusting thing about pak-study book is that it teaches you that we got independence from the Hindus and not from the Britishers I have also studied pak-study myself and i didint know about the britishers until few years ago. Poor children's are being lied to and brainwashed by the state.

  • @MKK126
    @MKK126 5 годин тому

    Is Sanjay Hindu living in Pakistan?

  • @samyagcharitra9719
    @samyagcharitra9719 5 годин тому

    Muhammad Qasim, Muhammad Ghouri ,Tipu Sultan, Akbar, Aurangzeb......The Heroes 😂

    • @samyagcharitra9719
      @samyagcharitra9719 5 годин тому

      India also teaches more or less same History as Pakistan, especially about Islamic invasion because of Muslim Education Ministers.

    • @samyagcharitra9719
      @samyagcharitra9719 5 годин тому

      It's romantic narration of rapp iists, plunn drurs, qil lers and con ver ters.

  • @RajivKBanyan
    @RajivKBanyan 6 годин тому

    I am your generation as well from Allahabad now Prayagraj. Delightful dialog. For many of us Indians animosity goes back to support for terrorism in India. With that support going down recently there is a phase lag before our insecurities will be improved. Keep the dialog going pl.

  • @muhamadmagsi2298
    @muhamadmagsi2298 6 годин тому

    shame on you biased mofo

  • @wasifnawaz4295
    @wasifnawaz4295 7 годин тому

    Thank you both of you for a candid conversation, there should be more sessions to be held like this

  • @KhurramSharif-eu1ow
    @KhurramSharif-eu1ow 7 годин тому

    Great report.

  • @rommeltito123
    @rommeltito123 8 годин тому

    "Usse pehle toh yehi milega"..... ummm no..... before that you will find holocaust of Hindus at the aegis of Mughals. From mass rapes to building heads of severed Hindu heads. The only thing that changed after the British invaded was such calamity was no longer possible in the open.

  • @user-cu2jn2eu3t
    @user-cu2jn2eu3t 8 годин тому

    Shehzad's analysis is relevant and helpful for a Pakistani audience...you're trying to make common cause with a segment of political opinion in India while conveniently forgetting 77 years of aggression towards India on every battlefield available. Put yourself in an Indian's shoes for a moment. How naive and self-destructive do you think we are?

  • @wkhan5
    @wkhan5 8 годин тому

    The assertion that Jinnah drank whiskey and ate pork is from one source- MC Chagla. He fell out with Jinnah and had an axe to grind and I would think hence the accusations. Despite Jinnah having had others in his close inner circle, no other source has ever alluded to such living practices of Jinnah. So I think it would be best to mention these accusations with a caveat rather than presenting them as almost indisputable facts

    • @ThePakistanExperience
      @ThePakistanExperience 8 годин тому

      www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/389424

    • @wkhan5
      @wkhan5 8 годин тому

      @@ThePakistanExperience if you would care to read that book, in an effort to convey that assertion, Wolpert again references only MC Chagla, not anyone else. So please try better

    • @ThePakistanExperience
      @ThePakistanExperience 7 годин тому

      If you have the book at home, go to page 72 and read the account of Ruttie’s close friend, Kanji

    • @wkhan5
      @wkhan5 7 годин тому

      @@ThePakistanExperience are you referring to the account where Jinnah supposedly asks Kanji to have a “drink with him and to stay on for dinner”. The drink may be alcohol or may equally be non-alcoholic. Can’t deduce the former to be definitively true based on that account.

    • @ThePakistanExperience
      @ThePakistanExperience 7 годин тому

      It is pretty obvious what “have a drink” means

  • @ameerkakar2910
    @ameerkakar2910 9 годин тому

    That’s so right shehzad, in ki jang me ham or pakistan affect ho rhy hai… You are doing great. Thank you.

  • @sushilrajak_77789
    @sushilrajak_77789 9 годин тому

    India ke bare me baat kar rahe hai batao inko koi tum arab ho hum indians hai.

  • @Islamic-Naats-n-Video-Channel
    @Islamic-Naats-n-Video-Channel 9 годин тому

    **Long Story Short** I Can Pray K Allah Pak Mujhe Data Gunj Baksh (R.A) Hazrat Ameer Muavia (R.A) BaYazeed Bastami (R.A) K Sath Uthaye Qayamat Mn NOW YOU PRAY K ALLAH PAK APKO AP K JEHLMI ENGINEER K SATH UTHAYE, You Can't Pray 😅 As You Already Know Jehlmi Jahannumi Hi Hai 😅 Shame On Ur Situation, K Jis Khabees Ko Din Raat Sun.ty Ho Us K Sath Marny Ki Dua Ni Kar Sakty 😂😂😂

  • @Islamic-Naats-n-Video-Channel
    @Islamic-Naats-n-Video-Channel 9 годин тому

    Sun Lo Naara GHUFFRAN Da, MIRZA JEHALMi HARAAM Da 🔥🔥🔥 ALLAH PAK ENGINEER K FITNY SE BACHAYE SABKO ☑️ Damage Has Been Done ❌❌❌ Engineer Has Been Run ✅✅✅ 😅😅😅 After 26 nov میں ہوں بریلوی میں ہوں بابی وڑ گیا جہلم کا فسادی🥴🥴🥴 ALHAMDULLILLAH i am Sunni Hanfi Brelvi Muslim ♥️♥️♥️

  • @muhammadtayyab2004
    @muhammadtayyab2004 10 годин тому

    Tuj jesy jahil k samne mic kisne rakh diya hy

  • @palestinelucas
    @palestinelucas 10 годин тому

    Pakistan military is the biggest enemy of pakistan

  • @haariskhan101
    @haariskhan101 10 годин тому

    Exposing a fraud in shape of sahil adim well done shehzad bhai your hosting skills are the best and the right way to host a show more power to you

  • @artus198
    @artus198 10 годин тому

    Notice the parallels here - the same thing was done to native cultures in - America, Canada, South America, Australia, New Zealand... This entire hate was introduced by the whyte man, in the Indian subcontinent, to weaken the civilization of this place.